Loading Events



July 2, 9:30pm10:30pm.

Will you accept this rose? It’s Bachelor Island – an improvised musical dating show inspired by the tropes of reality TV hits like The Bachelor and Love Island!

The audience takes on the role of casting director, creating our contestants – everyone from Ashley P., a model/actor from Los Angeles, to Bingus Bungus, a cotton candy inspector from the moon. After you meet the cast, sit back and enjoy a full season of Bachelor Island, full of love songs, jealousy, emotional confessionals, and a dramatic final rose ceremony. Featuring music and lyrics made up on the spot, love will be in the air at Caveat this summer!

Bachelor Island is created and performed by Hey, Handsome! (Paddy Boroughs, Max Feldman, Jackie Ferro, and Jenny Shaw).


21 A Clinton St
New York, NY 10002 United States